Skip to content

How we rate condition

What the number out of 10 on a listing is actually claiming, and how you can check it yourself.

The condition rating, out of 10

Our technician rates each handset from 1 to 10 for cosmetic condition — one overall score, judged across the front, the back and the edges. The bands below are defined by the distance at which a mark becomes visible. We use distance rather than words like “light wear” because two members of staff rating the same handset should reach the same answer, and because you can check the claim yourself with the phone in your hand.

samsung S22 ultr Burgundy 512 rated 9–10
9–10
No visible marks at any distanceA 9 or 10 also needs battery health of 90% or more.
apple iPhone X rated 7–8
7–8
Micro-scratches, not visible from 20 cm
apple iPhone 17 Pro Max rated 5–6
5–6
Light marks, not visible from 50 cm
1–4
Visible scratches or small dents; function unaffected

Battery health

Battery health is its own number on every listing, separate from the condition rating. A handset needs at least 80% before we will publish it at all, and a 9–10 rating needs 90% or more.

They are kept apart because they wear independently and buyers weigh them differently — some will take a 4/10 body with a 95% battery over a 10/10 one at 81%. Folding the battery into the rating would take that choice away. Where a battery has already been replaced, the listing says so.

Parts

Every listing states whether the parts are genuine, unknown, or unverified. The check follows Apple’s Parts and Service History where the handset reports it, and is recorded as one of those three values rather than as a yes-or-no — because “we could not tell” is a different statement from “we checked and they are not”.

What the rating does not cover

A handset can look perfect and still be locked to a network, imported, or unregistered with the PTA. Those are recorded separately and shown on the listing before you can add anything to a cart — PTA and IMEI explains what each one means for you.